In lieu of recent events on this blog and in the larger political community, and with an eye to the intense political debates that will no doubt be occurring in the next two months, I have decided to coin a term that may be helpful to us all. That term is "partisan dissonance". I'd suggest using the acronym PD in parenthesis as a citation.
It is my belief that this term has not been used before, which may make me something of a linguistic pioneer, though I do not claim to be as brilliant as Noam Chomsky (PD) in this area.
What is partisan dissonance? It is a phenomena in which two intelligent members of society view an event, an idea, or the written word in two completely different ways because of their political beliefs. I will now cite a few examples of this phenomenon to better illustrate the point (note: these are fictional examples):
PARTISAN DISSONANCE EXAMPLE A:
Partisan 1: Barack Obama has no experience at all and is completely unprepared to be President.
Partisan 2: Obama has a large number of experiences which make him well qualified to be president, including his legal career, his time in the Illinois State Senate, his experience as a US Senator, and his leadership during his campaign. How can you not see how experienced he is? It is so obvious!
Partisan 1: None of these experiences are sufficient to show that he is prepared to be President. He did nothing when he had these jobs, so he doesn't have the qualifications to be president. How can you possibly think someone so inexperienced actually has enough experience to be president? It is so obvious that he doesn't!
Partisan 2: Oh yeah? Well Sarah Palin was in the PTA and then the mayor of a town the size of Hoopeston. Sure she is a governor, but only for a year-and-a-half and that state is one of the smallest in the country. Obviously she is completely unprepared to be vice-president!
Partisan 1: What are you talking about? She is a governor and therefore has more executive experience than Obama. If anything she is more qualified to be president than he is!
At this point, further discussion of these points is useless. This is an unfortunate case of partisan dissonance.
PARTISAN DISSONANCE EXAMPLE B:
Partisan 1: I can't believe we've had to suffer through eight years of conservative rule. It is time for a change!
Partisan 2: What are you talking about? Sure we've had eight years of George W. Bush, but he isn't a conservative. If anything, he is more liberal than conservative. Just look at the Medicare Prescription Drug Plan, or NCLB. Obviously these are not the creations of a real conservative. What we really need this year is a return to traditional conservativism.
Partisan 1: What planet are you living on? Are you really saying that a president who slashed taxes for the richest Americans and deregulated almost every federal agency is not a conservative? You're nuts!
Partisan 2: I'm nuts? You don't even know what conservativism is. Please provide 25-50 concrete examples of the "conservative" decisions Mr. Bush has made so I can refute them all.
Partisan 1: I'm not going to bother listing all of the things that Bush had done that can be considered conservative. You should provide 50-100 examples of "liberal" decisions made by Bush so I can refute then all!
At this point, further discussion of these points is useless. This is an unfortunate case of partisan dissonance.
PARTISAN DISSONANCE EXAMPLE C:
Partisan 1: The media is biased against Republicans. It is obvious from the way they treated Sarah Palin. They hate Republicans and are determined to make sure McCain doesn't win this election. I am disgusted by the media!
Partisan 2: The media is biased against Democrats. Look at the way they are fawning over Sarah Palin. Obviously these people want to make sure their corporate boss's party (the GOP) wins. I am disgusted by the media!
At this point, further discussion of these points is useless. This is an unfortunate case of partisan dissonance.
PARTISAN DISSONANCE EXAMPLE D:
Partisan 1: Sarah Palin's speech was so negative and full of lies.
Partisan 2: Palin's speech wasn't negative or full of lies. She was telling it like it is! She is a pit bull with lipstick on and you have no right to call her a liar. You're a sexist pig.
Partisan 1: Well, the Democrats would have never given a speech that stretched the truth like Palin did. And she made fun of community organizers! What is wrong with her? Does she hate America?
Partisan 2: She was not making fun of community organizers! She was just pointing out, in her pit-bull-with-lipstick way, that Obama thinks he is ready to be president because of his experience as a community organizer. Obviously you don't understand politics. There is a big difference between criticizing a candidate or a party's experience and criticizing an entire group of people.
Partisan 1: No there's not! She was totally making fun of community organizers! And why wouldn't she? Did you see that there were only like three minorities at the entire convention? Republicans have a major race problem, so "community organizers" are obviously fair game.
Partisan 2: What? You just called me a racist! How dare you say I am a racist. Why do you hate Republicans so much?
Partisan 1: I didn't call you a racist, I said your party has a race problem. Though I would add that several Republicans are now using racial terms to try to bring down Obama. But that doesn't mean you are a racist! There is a big difference between criticizing what the party does and criticizing an entire group of people.
Partisan 2: No there's not! You are calling all Republicans racist!
At this point, further discussion of these points is useless. This is an unfortunate case of partisan dissonance.
Researchers have yet to find a cure for partisan dissonance. Until that day, psychologists believe sufferers should band together to share their experiences with this disease. Maybe if we all work together to listen to each other's struggles with PD we can make the difference in the spread of this horrible disease. And maybe, just maybe, our children won't be forced to suffer as we have.
I'd like to make this thread a place for those us who suffer from PD to share our stories, our struggles, and our triumphs. From one sufferer to another, I say welcome!