I found this Op-Ed piece about the CU-MTD on Friday’s News-Gazette Online. I didn’t see it in the printed News-Gazette and thought it was worth commentary. It is an accurate assessment of the future appointment of Tom Berns.
Back to the future for transit district
Friday February 15, 2008
It looks like more of the same at the Champaign-Urbana MTD.
Those who find the relationship between the management and board of the Champaign-Urbana Mass Transit District entirely too cozy won't take comfort in the latest appointment to the MTD's board of directors.
Former state Rep. Tom Berns, who served on the MTD's board from 1976 to 1986, is returning to fill the spot being vacated by the independent-minded Paul Lucas. Following nomination by Champaign County Board chairman C. Pius Weibel, Berns' appointment was approved last week by the board's appointments committee and will voted on by the full board Feb. 21. Berns was the only applicant.
Given all the controversy surrounding previous appointments, Weibel said he "thought some more people might apply." Two years ago, there were six candidates for two vacancies, with longtime MTD board member George Friedman's effort to win another term rejected.
So despite the controversy and pending litigation over the MTD's unpopular territorial expansion, either the critics don't care or they've given up trying to influence appointments. Given the depth of hostility, it's more likely the MTD's critics have given up on winning appointments of those skeptical of management. In the breakdown between MTD skeptics and cheerleaders, Berns would have to fall in the latter camp. Frankly, it's no surprise because people willing to serve believe in the importance of public transportation.
But the MTD's board has been legitimately criticized for extending Managing Director Bill Volk a double-digit employment contract and overseeing a generous pay package and an even more generous pension. As for policy issues, board members generated considerable ill will when they fell into line behind the MTD's forced expansion of its borders despite incredible hostility from residents who want neither the service nor the taxes that go with it.
Given his professional and personal relationships with MTD managers, it's hard to believe Berns will bring any change to the board's governance. But he should be encouraged to be skeptical. No management deserves a blank check from its overseers.
The MTD continues to be the one governmental body that somehow eludes the same scrutiny as other bodies like the Champaign and Urbana City Councils and the County Board. For example, the last MTD budget lists:
Dues and Subscriptions $ 48,000
Travel and Meetings $ 40,000
Public Information $ 125,000
Other Miscellaneous $ 48,000
These are just a few line items that seem excessive year after year (the salaries and benefits for the top administration is another attention-grabber). The only trustee that ever questioned the budget, Paul Lucas, has just retired. “No management deserves a blank check from its overseers” (N-G). Once appointed by the County Board, MTD continues to rubber stamp the management and its checkbook. I wish I was more optimistic that the needed changes might happen.